Post Payton Era?

Ethen Meyers • January 29, 2022

What does Payton’s departure mean for the Saints?
       
Honestly, what doesn’t it mean? I will be the first to admit that I missed a major clue that the end was near when he walked away from the competition committee. I thought for sure he would leave when Drew did but had no idea it would be in the form of retirement. His aggressive, yet calm ways forever changed the game of football, and the way New Orleans Saint’s fans see football. I certainly believe I can speak for everyone, he will be missed greatly and he will forever represent “The Rebirth”. Even if you were a Sean Payton critic or hater, you still have to feel like you were going to break things off with someone, and they beat you to the punch.

My Three Options:
       
Everyone has said Dennis Allen, or Leftwich, and there has been quite a stir around KC Chiefs OC Eric Bieniemy, but I have to ask, do we have the roster these guys were blessed with? We have one of the most efficient and impressive backs in the league, but there is absolutely a drop-off of talent on the offensive side of the ball when you look beyond Ian Book. Kidding, of course, I absolutely mean Alvin Kamara. If Micheal Thomas comes back half the player he left, he will be a breath of fresh air for any coach, but that still leaves us a few Tyreek Hill’s short of a star-studded roster. All that being said, I want to explore the obvious options, and then some options that are less mentioned.

 

Option 1:
       
Dennis Allen. This is an obvious one. We have slugged by with subpar offensive and elite defensive play. Pete Carmichael at the OC, Dennis Allen being promoted to HC, and Michael Hodges(the Saint’s current linebacker coach) to DC you provide the most logical promote within the method and offer the easiest transfer of culture, and stability. There is no doubt that the locker room loves DA, and Carmichael is a proven play-caller with a top 10 streak that holds weight all the way back to the merger in 1970. I believe with our current setup, this option would make the most sense for everyone, and allow us to retain two very important pieces of the staff in DA and Carmichael.

 

Option 2:
        Doug Pederson. Some folks may grab the pitchforks for this one, but hear me out. He IS a Super Bowl-winning coach and made Carson Wentz and Nick Foles look like franchise QBs. That would be in my opinion the equivalent of taking someone like the McCown brothers to the big game and winning it. Not only did he win a Super Bowl with Wentz and Foles, but he made Wentz a front runner for MVP, and the eventually crowned king of Philly the Super Bowl MVP Foles. He also comes from the Andy Reid coaching tree, and is a former career backup at QB, just like our beloved Payton. He also boasts a winning record as a head coach in both the regular season and in the postseason. I am not sure what Pederson did to be ignored from most HC vacancies, but most of the teams passing on him have a history of bad hires, so maybe that is a good sign. Also, it’s almost become a comedy watching people spell Payton as “Peyton” so we could find some continuity in this option because people would surely spell it “Peterson”. And if you are a ULM fan, he shares your alma matter.


Option 3:
        Mike Tomlin. Now I am not saying this one is possible, as he is under contract, but with Big Ben out, and a similar roster with a question mark by QB Tomlin is an interesting option that may be worth a phone call at a minimum. Couple that with the fact that the Steelers GM stepping down marks another question mark that can directly affect Tomlin’s future in the sea of Terrible Towels. All that considered, you add in the fact that the AFC North is seemingly getting stronger than ever(looking at you Burrow), and the NFC South’s departure of Brady looks like the Failcons have the most consistent roster going into the offseason, Tomlin could certainly be looking for a change of scenery where the grass is the same shade of green, just a little easier to water. Plus, he is, by definition, one of the winningest coaches in the NFL. He boasts 9 playoff appearances in 14 years and has pretty well dominated the AFC North racking up 1st place in 7 of those 14 years. His success in Pittsburg came after one Bill Cowher stepped down but didn’t “retire” citing more time with family, and that his coaching career may not be over. Sound familiar? Dallas has for years been after Payton, so I figured I could have a little bit of fun with stealing another HC for a change, and I love the idea of a guy with lit locker rooms and do your job culture to come down to the south and prove he can dominate anywhere. There are zero indications Tomlin is looking to move on, but we were all shocked by the Anthony Davis-Sean Payon behind-the-scenes drama, so maybe I can stir up some truth in the fiction.

In Summary:
       
As I say with most of my writing, I am just a guy with zero sources and ideas I like to share. Sean Payton will be severely missed, and I just wanted to explore some options I don’t think I have seen a lot, or at all(looking at you Tomlin). I think the most likely option is number 1, but that doesn’t mean it’s the one that happens. Nonetheless, if we can make it through the adversity of the last few years without rioting, I think we have a new head coach adjusting and prospering under control. Even if the first one doesn’t work out, maybe it leads us to a better option in the years following. If you are a Pelicans fan, you know exactly how this worked out to our benefit in The Blender

A quick share helps us a lot!

By Kaden Arkeder • November 19, 2026
It is Week 11 for the Saints and they find themselves at 3-6 preparing to go on the road to face a quality Chicago Bears team. The Bears have a potent offense led by Ben Johnson and Caleb Williams and a respectable defense thanks to a familiar face in Dennis Allen. On paper the Saints appear outgunned and probably do not have a lot of going for them in this matchup but despite the odds the team will have to find a way to be competitive and put themselves in a position to win. Finding a way to be competitive has been difficult for the Saints so far this season as the slow starts on offense and the bend don't break defense has been too much for them to overcome other than the occasional Tyler Shough late game heroics. The same issues have been persisting all season, slow starts on offense, no run game, bad play calling with no real sequencing, turnovers, not being able to stop the run, coming up with key stops to seal games on defense. The real problem has been the coaching staff not being able to come up with solutions to any of these issues. If they were able to solve some of these problems they would be better than 3-6 this season and not have all the public outcry about people's jobs. But when the product has looked the way it has for a while now you can't blame them. Fans do not get the credit they deserve at times because they can see past all the coach speak and understand the writing is on the wall when there are this many issues impairing the Saints ability to win football games and nothing improving in those areas. So with half the season left it begs to question what exactly is the best path forward for the Saints? They could fire the head coach mid season again and begin to drain the tub of this regime. I am sure plenty of fans would be open to this path even if the consequences do not result in wins. The Saints would most likely promote Brandon Staley in this scenario and let him finish this season off. Stands to reason the defence would probably have some fall off as he cannot just squarely focus on that side of the ball. Or the Saints could wait this out till the end of the season and make their changes then. I think both of these paths lead to the exact same place of needing to find another head coach and maybe more importantly new front office staff. I also think there is a third path here that appears as the most unlikely, which is the Saints could simply win more than lose from here on out and make a case that the people in leadership positions deserve more time to see this era of Saints football through. Should this happen I believe the coaching staff will have finally found the answers they have been seeking all season to the Saints issues and probably had some outside luck go their way. It is easy to look at this path and think winning games would be the most ideal scenario but would winning only mask all the issues plaguing the Saints? You could argue winning would just play into this illusion the Saints are better than what their record has been the past few seasons and just need another offseason to finally break out of their playoff drought. As much as I would like to see the Saints rattle off multiple victories this path is unlikely to be taken based on the mounting evidence stacked against this rendition of the Saints. Personally I believe the best path forward is sticking with the coaching staff the rest of the season and making changes once the season is over. In my eyes evaluators of the Saints have already seen enough and have been given plenty of time already to make those decisions at the end of the season. So waiting another eight games before making any changes should hardly change the outcome when they ultimately happen. Which could make these next two months feel very long and strenuous but should allow the Saints to make the best decision for their future moving forward. This also would appear the most likely path taken of these three since the front office staff have been in place so long Gayle Benson would prefer to give them the respect of letting them finish the season rather than being fired midway through if changes are indeed made in the front office. The idea of having new leadership from the front office down has long been such a far fetched idea. We as fans and those who cover the team have long dismissed the possibility of change. But as it stands today I believe we have never been closer to that reality coming to fruition. So here at the mid way point of the season I'll be shifting my vision to having one eye on the week at hand and the other on what the horizon might look like for a Saints organization which has been lost in mediocrity for far too long.
By Chrissy Smith • November 18, 2026
Team Stats (Warriors @ Pelicans) Final Score: 94-115 Rebounds: 50-57 Assists: 21-25 Blocks: 8-5 Steals: 5-11 Turnovers: 16-10 Stat Leaders (Warriors/Pelicans) Scoring Leaders: Yaxel Lendeborg, 28; Saddiq Bey, 23 Rebound Leaders: Draymond Green, Lendeborg, 8; Yves Missi, 14 Assist Leaders: Draymond Green, 5; Jeremiah Fears, 10 My Player of the Game: Jeremiah Fears Takeaways Jeremiah Fears became the youngest player to have a triple-double in Pelicans' franchise history. Yves Missi's defensive presence has been missed, and it's nice to have him back. Derik Queen went four-for-five from the three-point line. Follow The Kneaux on X , and follow me there too @SportsChrissy.
Show More