New Orleans Saints vs New York Giants 2025 Week 5 Recap

Greyson Jenkins • October 5, 2025

After a long 300 day wait, the Saints are finally back in the win column.


New Orleans Saints 26 - 14 New York Giants


The Saints were 1.5 point favorites going into their home matchup against the Giants, the team they had their most recent win against… in December of last year. Spencer Rattler joined the infamous group of NFL quarterbacks to start their career with 10 straight losses, but bounced back with his first career win. This team is one that has been looking for a positive boost to the season and it has finally arrived. 


The Positives

First things first, congratulations to Spencer Rattler. His whole career to this point has been working with backups or fighting for a spot against Tyler Shough, and although he has been playing well, a win was necessary to keep the discussions from getting louder. Prior to this game, Rattler was relying on shorter passes, and the deep balls he has been throwing have been inconsistent at best. He finally connected perfectly on one today with Rashid Shaheed for an 87 yard touchdown, the only offensive touchdown scored today. Oh, and did I mention this was the longest offensive touchdown for the Saints since Drew Brees was our quarterback? Rattler put up a solid final statline with 20 completions on 30 attempts for 225 yards and one touchdown. He avoided putting the ball in harm's way, and before rewatching, seemed to make the right decisions on most passing plays. He also had a solid game on the ground, with 21 yards on 6 carries. This is exactly the type of game us fans have wanted to see from Rattler, and if he can build off of this, the Saints may have their guy.

Kellen Moore had a solid game today with the offensive scheme, as it got 7 different receivers the ball (not including Rattler’s fluke reception), got Kendre Miller over 10 touches again, and reintroduced Taysom Hill with a small role. I’ve given Kellen Moore a good amount of knocks this season, and I have one I want to mention later, but the aggressive move to go for it on 4th and 5 late in the 4th quarter was something I loved seeing. Kellen Moore showed confidence in his guys by going for it here, especially in Rattler, calling a quick pass play that ended in a first down to Rashid Shaheed on a slant. In addition to this, towards the end of the game he fed Kendre Miller, who looked unstoppable on every rush. Kendre Miller was Dennis Allen’s enemy number one, and Kellen Moore has given him a much needed fresh start. As we saw last week vs the Bills, Kendre Miller seems like the best pure rusher on the team right now, which isn’t a slight to Saints legend Kamara, it just is a compliment to how talented Kendre is. He is one of the league’s top running backs in yards after contact and missed tackles forced, so it is essential for this offense that he keeps getting the ball. 


The defense and secondary came alive in this one, with 5 turnovers, 3 of which were fumble recoveries, and 2 being much needed interceptions by Kool-Aid McKinstry. I will talk about the defense’s struggles later, but after the first two drives the defense allowed zero, yes zero, points. They held all Giants rushers outside of Jaxson Dart to less than 4 yards per carry, and got a good amount of pressure on Dart when they brought more than 4 rushers. In addition, we saw Justin Reid go down early in this one with a concussion, forcing Jordan Howden to step up into his role. Jordan Howden and Jonas Sanker looked like a promising duo on the field together, both constantly crashing down to make tackles and both looking solid in coverage. Not only did these two and Kool-Aid step up, but Bryan Bresee had multiple pressures and also forced the fumble on Jordan Howden’s fumble return touchdown. This is a team that is in need of young players to step up, and today the young players on defense did just that.


The Negatives


Although the majority of this game was positive for the Saints, it’s still important to note that there were a few things that need to be improved. The penalties came back in this one, 7 being called on them with false starts and offsides from the offense causing setbacks on drives. The most notable penalty came after Taysom Hill completed a pass to Juwan Johnson to get them to the Giants’ 7 yard line. Torrecelli Simpkins false started on 1st down, leading to 1st and goal from the 12, and the Saints being held to a field goal.


Red zone struggles continued for the team, who are now down at 50% conversion rate for touchdowns in the endzone. They went 0-3 in the redzone today, with playcalling in the area being questionable and execution not being there. Kellen Moore has had moments every game that I question, and the biggest one that comes to mine was the pass play to Kamara with 11 seconds left before the half. With just 11 seconds left, you would expect a pass play that gets to the endzone, and instead no receivers ran past the sticks. The target was a quick out to Kamara, who had no shot at getting out of bounds or to the endzone, and the team had to burn their final timeout with 6 seconds left and ultimately settle for a field goal.


The Saints defense and secondary flashed today, but Staley’s scheme has me questioning any chance the team has of the performance being consistent. Staley has been vocal about his belief of limiting the explosive plays, and that they’ve done, but on the first two drives the Giants were getting anything on the field they wanted in the pass game short of 20 yards down the field. Staley has had the DBs off about 7-10 yards on majority of plays, and seemed to only rush 4 for the good majority of the first half. When doing this, the Giants were able to pick apart the zone defense, and there was essentially zero pressure being put on Dart. It was good to see this change after the defense allowed two straight easy touchdowns, and I hope to see the Saints defense improve every week from here on out.


The final negative, Blake Grupe. Although Grupe did make 4 field goals, he also missed 2 from 52 and 46 yards out. The first could have been due to an announcer’s jinx, if you’re the superstitious type, but the second was just a straight up miss. In games where the saints aren’t able to build a lead like they did today, it can help lead to losses, which we did see play out a few times this season already. Kellen Moore needs to do something about this, whether that be bringing in kickers to tryout, or having a mini-competition between Smyth and Grupe this week at practice.



Closing and Team MVPs


In all honesty, I have waited too long for the Saints to win a game, so I’m going to bask in the glory of this one, even though it was against a team that isn’t exactly great. I’m happy for Spencer Rattler, Kellen Moore, and for the team to finally have some positive momentum. Now, it’s up to the team to take this momentum and put it towards the next two weeks, with winnable games against the Patriots and Bears. 


Offensive MVP: Spencer Rattler


Defensive MVP: Whole defense, they all played their hearts out


Special Teams MVP: NONE.


A quick share helps us a lot!

By Kaden Arkeder • November 19, 2026
It is Week 11 for the Saints and they find themselves at 3-6 preparing to go on the road to face a quality Chicago Bears team. The Bears have a potent offense led by Ben Johnson and Caleb Williams and a respectable defense thanks to a familiar face in Dennis Allen. On paper the Saints appear outgunned and probably do not have a lot of going for them in this matchup but despite the odds the team will have to find a way to be competitive and put themselves in a position to win. Finding a way to be competitive has been difficult for the Saints so far this season as the slow starts on offense and the bend don't break defense has been too much for them to overcome other than the occasional Tyler Shough late game heroics. The same issues have been persisting all season, slow starts on offense, no run game, bad play calling with no real sequencing, turnovers, not being able to stop the run, coming up with key stops to seal games on defense. The real problem has been the coaching staff not being able to come up with solutions to any of these issues. If they were able to solve some of these problems they would be better than 3-6 this season and not have all the public outcry about people's jobs. But when the product has looked the way it has for a while now you can't blame them. Fans do not get the credit they deserve at times because they can see past all the coach speak and understand the writing is on the wall when there are this many issues impairing the Saints ability to win football games and nothing improving in those areas. So with half the season left it begs to question what exactly is the best path forward for the Saints? They could fire the head coach mid season again and begin to drain the tub of this regime. I am sure plenty of fans would be open to this path even if the consequences do not result in wins. The Saints would most likely promote Brandon Staley in this scenario and let him finish this season off. Stands to reason the defence would probably have some fall off as he cannot just squarely focus on that side of the ball. Or the Saints could wait this out till the end of the season and make their changes then. I think both of these paths lead to the exact same place of needing to find another head coach and maybe more importantly new front office staff. I also think there is a third path here that appears as the most unlikely, which is the Saints could simply win more than lose from here on out and make a case that the people in leadership positions deserve more time to see this era of Saints football through. Should this happen I believe the coaching staff will have finally found the answers they have been seeking all season to the Saints issues and probably had some outside luck go their way. It is easy to look at this path and think winning games would be the most ideal scenario but would winning only mask all the issues plaguing the Saints? You could argue winning would just play into this illusion the Saints are better than what their record has been the past few seasons and just need another offseason to finally break out of their playoff drought. As much as I would like to see the Saints rattle off multiple victories this path is unlikely to be taken based on the mounting evidence stacked against this rendition of the Saints. Personally I believe the best path forward is sticking with the coaching staff the rest of the season and making changes once the season is over. In my eyes evaluators of the Saints have already seen enough and have been given plenty of time already to make those decisions at the end of the season. So waiting another eight games before making any changes should hardly change the outcome when they ultimately happen. Which could make these next two months feel very long and strenuous but should allow the Saints to make the best decision for their future moving forward. This also would appear the most likely path taken of these three since the front office staff have been in place so long Gayle Benson would prefer to give them the respect of letting them finish the season rather than being fired midway through if changes are indeed made in the front office. The idea of having new leadership from the front office down has long been such a far fetched idea. We as fans and those who cover the team have long dismissed the possibility of change. But as it stands today I believe we have never been closer to that reality coming to fruition. So here at the mid way point of the season I'll be shifting my vision to having one eye on the week at hand and the other on what the horizon might look like for a Saints organization which has been lost in mediocrity for far too long.
By Chrissy Smith • November 18, 2026
Team Stats (Warriors @ Pelicans) Final Score: 94-115 Rebounds: 50-57 Assists: 21-25 Blocks: 8-5 Steals: 5-11 Turnovers: 16-10 Stat Leaders (Warriors/Pelicans) Scoring Leaders: Yaxel Lendeborg, 28; Saddiq Bey, 23 Rebound Leaders: Draymond Green, Lendeborg, 8; Yves Missi, 14 Assist Leaders: Draymond Green, 5; Jeremiah Fears, 10 My Player of the Game: Jeremiah Fears Takeaways Jeremiah Fears became the youngest player to have a triple-double in Pelicans' franchise history. Yves Missi's defensive presence has been missed, and it's nice to have him back. Derik Queen went four-for-five from the three-point line. Follow The Kneaux on X , and follow me there too @SportsChrissy.
Show More