How to fix the Saints

Chris Nalls • October 2, 2023

How to fix the Saints


Listen, it is time we face the truth. The Saints are good on paper but don't show it on the field. The offense could be better, and quarterback Derek Carr has only thrown for a total of two touchdowns in four games. Now, not all the blame is on Carr, however. Offensive coordinator Pete Carmichael needs to improve in play calling. What is it precisely that the New Orleans Saints need to do? Glad you asked. Let's take a look at a few options. 


Let's start with the quarterback position. There is little the Saints can do now with Carr. They will have to ride it out all season, but it is time to start looking at drafting a franchise quarterback. The Saints have ignored the quarterback position in the early draft rounds, and that has to change this year. When the Saints traded up to select Marcus Davenport and bypassed Lamar Jackson,  it set this franchise back. Imagine having Lamar behind center instead of Carr. This year's quarterback draft class is loaded with many great options.


There are so many quarterbacks the Saints need to explore. You have Caleb Williams, Jordan Travis, Drake Maye, Michael Penix Jr., J.J. McCarthy, and Quinn Ewers. The Saints have to look at one of these many franchise-changing quarterbacks. The Saints won't get Caleb Williams, but you have to list him in case the Saints get crazy and try to make a trade for him, which is highly unlikely. Once they draft their guy, let him sit and learn behind Carr since he is signed to a massive contract for the next two years. It all starts with having a franchise quarterback. The roster is rarely young at the skills positions. You have wide receiver Chris Olave, Rashid Shaheed, running back Kendre Miller, and tight end Juwan Johnson. Insert a quarterback and boom, the Saints are back on top of this division. 


Another issue the Saints have that needs to be addressed is firing head coach Dennis Allen and offensive coordinator Pete Carmichael. Dennis Allen has never been that great of a head coach, and the Saints wanted someone familiar from the Sean Payton era to keep the magic alive. Unfortunately, Allen is a much better defensive coordinator than he is head coach. Now, Pete Carmichael needs to be fired immediately. The Saints have only scored 20 points this season once. You will not survive in the NFL, scoring at most 20 points. 


There are a few coordinators the Saints should go after as head coach. Below are a few


Eric Bieniemy - Commanders Offensive Coordinator

Ben Johnson- Lions Offensive Coordinator

Ken Dorsey-Bills Offensive Coordinator


These three stand out to me and could be viable options for the Saints next season. What Bieniemy is doing with Sam Howell at the quarterback position and putting the Commander's offense in place to win games is something the Saints desperately need. Johnson and Dorsey, well, look at those offenses. The Lions are 3-1 on the season, and Jared Goff looks like he did when he played for the Rams. The Bills are doing what the Bills do: win and score many points.


 Regarding the offensive coordinator position, I would promote Doug Marrone for the rest of this season. Marrone is a former head coach who would fill in great for now. After the season, Saint would need to evaluate if they hire a new head coach. The time for change is this offseason period. Stop avoiding the inevitable and embrace it. The Saints need to get rid of the Sean Payton era. The only way to achieve this will be by drafting a franchise quarterback and hiring a new head coach. This will lay the foundation of a new era.


Be sure to follow on Twitter @TheChrisNalls

A quick share helps us a lot!

By Garrison Giddens June 12, 2026
Discussing how the Pelicans get into the lottery & a few prospects to keep in mind. 
247Sports All-Time Commits rankings showing player cards with photos and ratings; Tylan George and Jordyn Crites visible
By Patrick Harkness June 12, 2026
Tulane Green Wave fans have plenty to celebrate this cycle and previous. According to the latest 247Sports composite rankings, the Green Wave have landed the two highest-rated recruits in program history for the Class of 2026, and they’re not just any two prospects. Tylan George, the massive interior offensive lineman from West Monroe High School in Louisiana, sits at No. 1 with a 0.8939 rating. The 6’3”, 310-pound 4-star prospect has been a dominant force on the offensive line, earning praise for his pancake block totals and elite strength (515-pound squat, 315 bench as a junior). George brings immediate size, power, and local pride to an offensive line room that’s hungry for impact talent. Right behind him at No. 2 is Jordyn Crites, the 6’6”, 255-260 pound defensive lineman from Friendswood High School in Texas. Crites recently earned his 4-star upgrade and a 0.8926 composite, making him one of the most athletic and long defensive linemen in the class (83-inch wingspan, 4.8 forty, 530-pound squat). He played both defensive end and tight end in high school and brings versatility, length, and upside that fits perfectly in Will Hall’s defensive scheme. Together, George and Crites represent a seismic shift in Tulane recruiting. Not only are they the top two in the 2026 class, but their ratings mark a new ceiling for what the Green Wave can attract. One bolsters the trenches on offense with mauling power; the other adds length and explosiveness on defense. Both have potential to contribute early and raise the floor (and ceiling) for their respective position groups. This isn’t just a good class, it’s a statement. Tulane is no longer just competing for regional talent; they’re landing blue-chip prospects who have Power conference offers and are choosing to build something special in New Orleans. The Green Wave are trending up, and these two are the new faces of that ascent. #RollWave #RMFW Make sure to follow Patrick Harkness on X
Show More