Final Saints 53-Man Roster Prediction

Jamie UK • August 28, 2023

I’ve done plenty of these by now so minimal analysis required here’s how I think the initial 53-man roster shakes out.

Offense

Quarterback (3)

  • Derek Carr
  • Jameis Winston 
  • Jake Haener 


        No analyses necessary here this is as clear as it gets, Carr will be the starter, Winston (baring an trades, which I wouldn’t expect unless there is a godly offer) and Haener will be the emergency third QB active on gamedays.


Running backs (3)

  • Alvin Kamara*
  • Jamaal Williams 
  • Kendre Miller


        Alvin Kamara will need to be carried on the initial 53 before being placed on the reserve/suspended list which will then give the Saints the roster spot back. I’m predicting that the Saints will not keep Ellis Merriweather on the 53, despite impressing but instead as its likely he will pass through waivers put him on the practice squad and then elevate him on gamedays to provide additional cover for Williams and Miller on gamedays. The same possibility exists for veteran RB Darrel Williams its even easier to do the same with him as he does not need to pass through waivers to be put on the practice squad.


        I’m also predicting that the Saints will not carry FB Adam Prentice on the 53 (to begin with) to allow the Saints to get keep other players who are a threat to be claimed by other teams. Instead, as he also doesn’t have to go through waivers either bring him back to 53 before week 1 once other players have been placed on IR or the suspended lists or also add him to the practice squad and elevate him for gamedays before signing him to the 53 later down the line.


Practice Squad Candidates- Ellis Merriweather, Darrel Williams, Adam Prentice


Wide Receiver (5)

  • Michael Thomas 
  • Chris Olave
  • Rashid Shaheed 
  • Tre’Quan Smith*
  • A.T. Perry


        Smith has an * because I think he be carried initially so that the team can then place him on short-term IR.  With that roster Spot I expect the Saints to bring back vet WR Keith Kirkwood in some capacity either to the 53 or on practice squad to begin with before signing him to the 53 later down the line.


        The final spot for me goes to A.T. Perry the Saints were very high on him in the draft and Perry, after a slow start had a really training camp and preseason. I hear Saints fans everywhere hollering where is Shaq Davis??? I’ve been high on Davis since the first preseason game (before he caught fire) but I don’t see there’s enough room on the roster at this stage to carry him as well, I’ve predicted throughout the off-season that he’s going to be a practice squad player. Not because I don’t rate him, but because I don’t think the Saints will put him on the 53 at this stage.


 Practice Squad Candidates- Shaq Davis, Lynn Bowden, Kawaan Baker and Jontre Kirklin


Tight End (4)

  • Juwan Johnson 
  • Foster Moreau
  • Taysom Hill
  • Jimmy Graham


        Another reason for there not being room for Shaq Davis is he is not just competing with Perry for a roster spot but he’s also competing with Graham. Both, mammoth pass catchers with a specific role centered around the red  zone, third downs and contested-catch situations. If the Saints didn’t sign Graham, I think Davis probably makes the team. 

Despite his strong showing in the final preseason game, I don’t think there’s room for Luca Krull, he hasn’t done enough to show he can be a consistent contributor over Graham after some bad drops in the 2nd preseason game, if he made those plays then I think this decision is a lot tougher.


Practice Squad Candidates- Lucas Krull, J.P Holtz


Offensive Line (9)

  • Trevor Penning
  • James Hurst
  • Erik McCoy
  • Cesar Ruiz
  • Ryan Ramczyk
  • Andrus Peat
  • Nick Saldiveri
  • Calvin Throckmorton 
  • Landon Young*


        I’ve maintained these 9 names for the offensive line in all of my predictions, the only difference here is I think Young is carried initially before going short-term IR to finishes his recovery from a sprained MCL, once this is done, I expect the Saints to bring back backup RT Storm Norton.

I could see the Saints keeping 10 here and keeping veteran Center Max Garcia to be the primary backup for Erik McCoy but I think they are going the practice squad route for now with Garcia, in the same way they did last year with vet Center Josh Andrews.


Practice Squad Candidates- Max Garcia, Lewis Kidd , Mark Evans and Tommy Kraemer


Defense 

Defensive Line (9)

  • Cam Jordan 
  • Carl Granderson
  • Payton Turner
  • Tanoh Kpassagnon 
  • Isiah Foskey
  • Bryan Bresee
  • Nathan Shepherd
  • Khalen Saunders
  • Malcolm Roach


        Nothing much to add here this feels like a pretty obvious group. DT Jack Heflin and DE Niko Lalos made late pushes with an impressive preseason and end to training camp. This group is to stacked with high draft picks and vets who have had brilliant off-seasons for either to crack the 53 at this stage and I expect both to be practice squad priorities for the Saints.


Practice Squad Candidates- Jack Heflin, Niko Lalos and Jerron Cage


Linebacker (6)

  • Demario Davis
  • Pete Werner 
  • Jaylon Smith
  • Zack Baun
  • D’Marco Jackson
  • Nephi Sewell 


        Same here as my previous projection, I think the Saints go 6 LBs due to the heavy usage that LBs have on special teams, Baun, Jackson and Sewell are expected to be featured heavily in this phase of the game, with all three having solid upside on defense should there be injuries. With Davis and Werner being the starters and Smith as the primary backup for either spot as well as the starting SAM LB.


        I would have liked to have found a spot for rookie UDFA Anfernee Orji, but I don’t see the Saints keeping 7 here and I don’t think he has enough upside to start in defense if needed at this stage, so I expect him to be a priority for the practice squad.


Practice Squad Candidates- Anfernee Orji, Ty Summers and Ryan Connelly (depending on Injury status)


Cornerback (5)

  • Marshon Lattimore
  • Paulson Adebo
  • Bradley Roby 
  • Alontae Taylor
  • Isaac Yiadom


        The top 4 goes without saying with the top three expected to be the starters with Taylor the primary backup on the outside. I’ve also kept Yiadom here as I expect him to be the starting Gunner on special teams opposite all pro special teamer J.T. Gray. Yiadom has also showed improvements on defense throughout the off-season so does have some value there too if needed.


        Rookie UDFA Anthony Johnson has also had a strong off-season but this position is too stacked for him to make the initial roster at this stage without the special teams ability that Yiadom has. I would expect him to be a priority for the practice squad.


Practice Squad Candidates- Anthony Johnson and Troy Pride Jr.


Safety (6)

  • Tyrann Mathieu 
  • Marcus Maye*
  • Jordan Howden
  • Lonnie Johnson Jr.
  • J.T. Gray
  • Ugo Amadi 


        Mathieu and Maye will be the starters with the primary backups expected to be Jordan Howden and Lonnie Johnson Jr. Crucially both players have played well on special teams throughout preseason so will provide good value in that phase, Howden also appears to be the preferred option in DIME packages. Amadi, appears to be the primary backup at slot CB and has good special teams value as a returner, gunner and on kick coverage. 


        Jonathan Abrams and Smoke Monday are unfortunately in my opinion the odd players out in a very deep position group. Both have had really solid off-seasons and any other years would be on the 53, I expect them both to be on the practice squad.


Practice Squad Candidates- Jonathan Abrams and Smoke Monday


Specialists (3)

  • Will Lutz
  • Blake Gillikin 
  • Zach Wood


        I hate not having Grupe on the 53, but with the Saints current win now mode and previous issues with Kickers when Lutz was injured barring a trade, I just think they are going to go with the incumbent starter over the unproven product.  I have applied the same rationale for the Punter, by going with Blake Gillikin.


Make sure to follow me on Twitter and Instagram @SaintsReportUK, for much more Saints content and discussion throughout the 2023 season and beyond.

A quick share helps us a lot!

By Chrissy Smith • November 18, 2026
Team Stats (Warriors @ Pelicans) Final Score: 94-115 Rebounds: 50-57 Assists: 21-25 Blocks: 8-5 Steals: 5-11 Turnovers: 16-10 Stat Leaders (Warriors/Pelicans) Scoring Leaders: Yaxel Lendeborg, 28; Saddiq Bey, 23 Rebound Leaders: Draymond Green, Lendeborg, 8; Yves Missi, 14 Assist Leaders: Draymond Green, 5; Jeremiah Fears, 10 My Player of the Game: Jeremiah Fears Takeaways Jeremiah Fears became the youngest player to have a triple-double in Pelicans' franchise history. Yves Missi's defensive presence has been missed, and it's nice to have him back. Derik Queen went four-for-five from the three-point line. Follow The Kneaux on X , and follow me there too @SportsChrissy.
By Kaden Arkeder • November 18, 2026
Watching the Saints has been like watching your favorite show being rewound and starting over week after week. I would love to talk about the Saints scoring a touchdown on an opening drive or a well drawn up and executed touchdown or the defense getting a key stop to seal a victory. Alas another game has gone by where neither of those stories exist for me to write about. This game against the Panthers had big implications for the Saints had they won as they would have taken the lead in the division for the woeful NFC South and would have won back to back games for the first time this season. But the Saints once again could not overcome a lackluster performance by the offense compounded by another slow start. The Saints opening drive seemed like it could have some traction with a solid first down and staying ahead of the chains for the most part until it quickly stalled and needing to convert on a fourth and short where Shough threw to a contested Olave and a broken up ball was intercepted by the defense. It was the first of multiple examples from this game where the playcalling just was not good enough. But on top of the opening turnover it was another opening drive where not only were the Saints unable to score but also set up the defense on a short field. Thankfully the defense was up to the task and were able to keep the Panthers from capitalizing and keeping the score 0-0 heading into the second quarter. In the second quarter the Saints could not get anything going on offense and the Panthers were able to take a 7-0 lead into the half. In the second half the offenses of both teams started to find their footing more and started trading scoring drives. Which sounds a lot like how most these games go for the Saints where they are unable to do much of anything on offense until the time within the game starts to become late. In his limited snaps in this game Alvin Kamara made the most of them by scoring both of the Saints only two touchdowns in the game. To the Saints credit they did enough to keep themselves in the game and even had the opportunity to seal the game late with a touchdown drive. But the last offensive drive was derailed by bad decisions by Tyler Shough to check the ball down instead of looking down the field and the ball carriers getting out of bounds instead of keeping the clock running by staying inbounds. With the game tied up the Panthers had thirty seconds and a timeout to get enough yards to kick a game winning field goal. Which they were able to pull off due to a questionable pass interference call. After the game you could see the toll is starting to take effect on Kellen Moore as his demeanor was noticeably different as were his answers to reporters' questions. Kellen said at the end they were playing for the win and not the tie which seemed like a tongue in cheek shot at Shough and his teammates' decisions on the last offensive drive. But in all honesty the whole operation is just not good enough and has been the case for a while now. When the Saints do win they are scraping by because of late game heroics from Tyler Shough and the defense doing just enough to keep games close and buying time for the offense to wake up halfway through the game. How the Saints have won has been unsustainable because of the whole offensive operation. You can point to key injuries to personnel, bad coaching, bad play calling, or bad execution but truly all of those are reasons why the Saints are sitting at 3-6 today. With a difficult three game stretch ahead against the Bears, Bengals, and Packers the Saints will have to start fixing these issues to show the season is not lost and why people should keep their jobs. For a team and coaching staff which has struggled to find answers all season, they better hope they find them quick otherwise these next three games could be quite embarrassing for everyone.
Show More