The Recap- Saints Vs Colts

Jamie UK • October 30, 2023

The Recap- Saints Vs Colts


Well, well, well the Saints offense picks the best time to produce their best game of the season exploding for 38 points and over 500 yards of offense, the defense started slow again but locked in with some great second-half adjustments to keep the Colts at bay.


Let's break down the most fun Saints game of the year, no Saints therapy is required this week.


Team Stats 


(Saints/Colts)


Final Score: 38-27

First downs: 24-19

3rd down efficiency: 6/12- 7/16

Total yards: 511-371

RedZone Efficiency:3 of 4- 2 of 3

Penalties: 8 for 73 yards- 6 for 30 yards

Turnovers- 1- 1

Time of possession- 30:09-29:51


Takeaways 


Offense


This was the offense I expected to see this year it's crazy that we’ve had to wait until week 8 to see it. Carr played his best game as a Saint today, he still missed a couple of throws 2 slants to Thomas and a throw to Olave where he overthrew him otherwise, this is exactly what you want to see from Carr and these are the types of performances that justify the contract the Saints gave him.


Pete Carmichael called a great game today, in fairness to him he did overall against the Jags too, the big difference is Carr executed far better in the game. The Taysom usage was perfect barring one play (I didn't like the deep ball call, it felt like the wrong time to take Carr out), I am especially loving the Khalen Saunders package with Taysom at the goal-line, which I'm going to call ‘The Bink Easy’ Package. The Saints are now 17-1 when Taysom Rushes the ball 7 or more times and 16-1 when he rushes for 40 more yards, pretty good for an overpaid gimmick player.


We saw AK out wide, run option routes out of bunch sets and the backfield and finally a Texas Route which went for an 18-tard touchdown to get the offense started. This is how Ak should be used every week, he's more than just a dump of machine. Now all I'm waiting for is an AK wheel route and some more screens, but this is a step in the right direction for Carmichael where AK is concerned in the passing game.


It’s been far too long since we’ve seen a Rashid Shaheed big play in the passing game and then we saw 3 in one game. Shaheed finished with a massive stat line 3 catches for 153 yards and a touchdown, all three of these were huge plays. That sounds obvious when you average 51 yards per catch, but let's look at each one:

  • Catch 1-  a 58-yard catch and run for a touchdown to give the Saints their first lead on the day.
  • Catch 2- Taysom Hill underthrows him, Shaheed comes back to the ball and battles with the DB to come up with the catch, after it was originally called an INT. The Saints go on to score to put them up 15.
  • Catch 3-  3 mins left in the 4th Saints up 7 it's 3rd and 13 reminiscent of week 1 against the Titans. Carr uncorks a beautiful deep ball for a 51-yard completion to ice the game.

Shaheed=Clutch.


A couple of quick hitters:

  • Mike Thomas was really good again, especially when we find out after the game he's barely eaten for two days due to the illness that swept the Saints locker room this week.
  • Thought Jamaal Williams looked really good running the ball today, definitely his best game as a Saint.
  • I thought the o-line held up well bar one play ( the Buckner forced fumble) one thing that has to change is the pre-snap penalties, way too many false starts today at one point there were 2 in 2 plays.



Defense


It was a very similar story for the defense this week as it was against the Texans. They started slow, the Colts ran on them at will, as the Texans did. Crucially as they have the last few weeks they adjusted really well and shut their opponent down in the second half. Only conceding ten points (would have only been 3 if not a crazy throw by Minshew) and again forced turnovers they are now up to 9 interceptions on the season (two more than their total from a season ago).


The secondary was fantastic this week, especially the CBs, Lattimore looked locked in barring a PI penalty. Taylor looked like he had his best game in the slot so far. The cream of the crop though was Paulson Adebo he was stifling in coverage, had an excellent interception and had another 3 PBUs. They looked like one of the best CB trio’s in the NFL  today.


My only gripe with the defense today is the D-line. I'm still not sold on them in run defense, yes they tightened up after the Colts early success but they are still proving they can be run on when a team wants to. Also, the pass rush is still all too quiet in games against competent o-lines there is only so long this elite secondary can cover with the pass rush not getting home consistently. 


Granderson and Jordan both had moments but it wasn't consistent enough. Cam having to play 80-odd % of the snaps every week as a 34-year-old DE is not the move. This team could really do with Payton Turner back sooner than later to help with the rotation to keep guys fresh or….. They go full YOLO all-in mode and trade for one of the many great DE options at the deadline, I’d rather they didn't pump more future draft capital into this team, particularly this coaching staff but I have to admit this defense without another plus starter at DE is an exciting thought, My personal choice would be Washington DE Montez Sweat who its been widely reported could be had for a 2nd round pick.


 

Saints Stock Exchange (Sponsored By… Nobody)


Just a quick hit section each week to highlight which Saints players/staff have their stock value increasing and decreasing after each game, 3 up and 3 down:


Stock Up


  • Derek Carr
  • Rashid Shaheed
  • Alvin Kamara


This was Carr’s best game as a Saint and if he plays like this the rest of the way the Saints are winning the South and hosting a playoff game (Big IF).


Rashid Shaheed shrugged off a couple of down weeks with missed assignments and chemistry issues to look like prime Randy Moss. There's no way I couldn't have him on this list.


The final spot was a tough one as I'm sure you are aware if you've read many of my articles/tweets I'm a big Taysom Hill fan he's my favourite Saints player I've watched so it pains me to not have him on this list, but I had to go AK here he looked explosive today in the passing game and is now tied for the 5th most games in NFL history (with Jim Brown) with now 11 games with a receiving and rushing TD.



Stock Down



  • Bryan Bresee
  • Erik McCoy
  • Chris Olave


I struggled to find specific players here but here’s my rationale:


Bresee had the costly illegal formation penalty which turned a Colts FG attempt into the Colts scoring a TD on 4th down, Bresee nearly had this exact penalty earlier in the season but Zack Baun Managed to just move his alignment pre-snap. Luckily it didn't cost the Saints today but it easily could have.


McCoy had one of the false starts I mentioned earlier he also got beat badly but Buckner on the Carr strip sack, little things but you would expect more from one of the highest paid Centers in the league.


Finally, I went with Olave, this feels a little harsh but he had a brutal drop on 3rd down which would have been a walk-in touchdown, at this point the Saints were only up 1. It was a beautiful route by Olave to get open and he looked like he lost the ball in the lights. Olave has had that issue a few times this year, I don't know how you fix it but he has to find a way because it has been a problem for him.

 

Conclusion 


It was great to see some good offensive football it feels like we haven't seen any for about 2 years so I'm going to enjoy this win i am not fooled into thinking this team's issues are fixed. There are still far too many penalties, some spot run defense and pass-rush.


This, however, was a damn good start we just need to see some consistency, something we have seen in the Dennis Allen era, the Saints are now tied for 1st in the NFC South, and have 2 winnable games up next against the potentially Justin Fields-less Chicago Bears and the definitely Kirk Cousins-less Vikings. If the Saints are who the say they are they should be going into their week 11 bye sitting pretty at 6-4, will they be who the hell knows with this team but after this game I'm looking forward to finding out.



Make sure to follow me on Twitter and Instagram @SaintsReportUK, for much more Saints content and discussion throughout the 2023 season and beyond. 


A quick share helps us a lot!

By Greyson Jenkins September 14, 2025
New Orleans Saints 21 - 26 San Francisco 49ers  What I was Looking for Following last week's game, where the offensive playcalling and time management appeared questionable, this team sought to bounce back on offense. In addition, the defense looked solid against the Kyler Murray-led Cardinals, so I wanted to see them look good against a 49ers team led by the average at best Mac Jones. The Notes I made before the game to look for were: How does Rattler look against a solid 49ers defense? How will Kellen Moore bounce back after a poorly called game 1? Does Juwan Johnson continue being a top target? How often does Brandon Staley blitz Mac? Rattler: Spencer Rattler had one noticeably bad missed touchdown to Olave on the first drive, but after that, he showed up and showed out. Rattler had his first multi-passing touchdown game of his career, finishing 25 of 34 for 207 yards and 3 touchdowns. This was by far Rattler’s best game of his career, and I believe this performance should encourage both the team and fans about his potential future as the starting quarterback. As I mentioned, the start was iffy, with him missing a wide-open touchdown to Olave behind him (should’ve been caught), and multiple drops by Juwan Johnson. He then went out and finished the game strong, at one point having 13 consecutive completions. Rattler looked confident in himself and his receivers, and also used his legs in multiple situations to help the team. All in all, this was a B+ performance by him, and if he can build off of it, it could completely change the team’s rebuilding decisions. Moore: I was avidly down on Kellen Moore as a playcaller last week, as he abandoned the run game and giving Alvin Kamara touches in the second half. This week, it appeared that Kellen Moore realized Alvin Kamara is a crucial playmaker in this offense, as he gave Alvin 21 carries spread throughout the game, which resulted in 99 yards. In addition, the passing game seemed much more diverse in depth of target as well as the routes being run, which is definitely encouraging in terms of his confidence in Rattler. In the future, I want to see Moore continue to improve each week as well as show some emotion on the sidelines, something I feel is lacking at the moment (and reminds me of Dennis Allen too much). Juwan Johnson: Juwan Johnson was the leading receiver last week, so I wanted to see if that would continue this week. He ended up being the 2nd leading target for Rattler, with 9 targets being just behind Olave’s 10. Outside of the 2 horrific drops, which justifiably made fans get the torches ready, Juwan was very productive and ended up bringing in a great touchdown reception. It appears he and Rattler do have a great connection brewing, and I would love for the redzone targets to continue this season. Brandon Staley Blitz Rate: The Saints blitzed just over 35% last week, and the defense seemed to get pretty consistent pressure against the Cardinals. This would lead one to believe that Brandon Staley would blitz an offense led by Mac Jones (who struggles against pressure), right??? Wrong. Throughout this game, I found myself dumbfounded by the lack of blitzing, and it seemed as though Mac Jones had all the time in the world to find at least one receiver down the field with lots of room around them. The worst part about this is that the Saints failed to get out of 3rd down situations, with two long 3rd down conversions on the 49ers' final touchdown drive, where Mac Jones faced zero pressure. With Chase Young missing from this DL, I knew Cam Jordan wouldn’t be able to replicate his 1.5 sack performance from last week, but I just wish Staley knew this as well. I hope Staley sees the lack of pressure this front 4 got for most of this one, and that he brings more pressure next week against the Seahawks. The Offense The Good: Alvin Kamara is still Alvin Kamara. As I previously mentioned, he had a great game on the ground, but also back as a pass catcher with 6 receptions for 21 yards. Spencer Rattler was also great on the ground, as he picked up multiple clutch 1st downs with his legs, making defenders miss tackles in the process. The Passing game looked to have significantly improved, with routes being more diverse and the ball being spread out to 7 different receivers. I love the confidence Rattler has in his guys, and I would also love to see more Vele targets in the redzone after his touchdown today. Finally, the last thing that is great to see is that the Saints went 3/3 in the redzone today, something that will be huge this season if they can continue succeeding at a high clip in that area. The Bad: The Saints' offense had more sloppy moments again today, with penalties bringing back 1st downs, easy balls being dropped, and big losses on early downs. Kellen Moore seemed to call a better game, but I hate that he went away from tempo, which was working wonders for Rattler and the offense. The offense struggled to convert on 3rd down, only being able to do so on 36% of them. Finally, although Kelvin Banks and the offensive line looked solid today, Banks and Fuaga both got beaten on crucial downs on the last two drives, something you don’t want to see from the two first-round picks. Something that also belongs technically in the bad column, but I see more as unlucky than anything, is that Alvin Kamara lost a fumble on a bang-bang play. I won’t hold it against him, as I’ve seen similar plays get ruled incomplete after review multiple times when watching NFL games. The Defense The Good: The Saints' defense looked solid to start the game, forcing a quick 3 and out after the Saints' offense stalled in 49ers territory. In addition, this defense stood up after struggling for the majority of the game after that first possession, by forcing two crucial stops in the 4th quarter. Carl Granderson continues to be a crucial piece for this defense in the absence of Chase Young, finishing the game with 2 sacks and now being tied for the NFL sack leader title. The safety play again by Justin Reid felt like a great piece of this defense, as he played great in the run game and was doing a good job communicating with the younger DBs around him. Kool-Aid McKinstry seemed to have a better outing this week, something the young corner can hopefully build on next week, going against a solid receiver group for the Seahawks. The Saints also forced their first turnover of the season, with Chris Rumph II having a huge strip-sack in the 3rd quarter. The Bad: After the pressures accrued early again in the game, the pressure felt non-existent in the second half, and Brandon Staley seemed to completely abandon all blitz packages. Alontae Taylor and Isaac Yiadom struggled massively in this one, with Alontae Taylor blowing a coverage on Christian McCaffrey, allowing a touchdown before the half, and Isaac Yiadom simply was picked on early and often throughout the game. The Saints need to consider Lincoln Riley starting over Yiadom, as the Saints will miss out on a compensatory pick if they continue with Yiadom this season. There were numerous big down plays that you could tell the 49ers would design to attack Yiadom as a weakness, and it worked wonders. In conclusion, I was extremely discouraged by the cornerback group, and I hope Staley goes back to blitzing at a higher rate next week against Sam Darnold. Special Teams: No positives jumped out to me with this group; the return game was solid, but punting seemed hit or miss by Kroeger, and Blake Grupe again missed another field goal. If Grupe makes that field goal early, the Saints would have possibly only needed a field goal on the final drive. Closing and Team MVPs This game felt like another game the Saints took themselves out of, and not one where the opposing team beat them. I did love the sparks that showed on offense, and if Spencer Rattler can build off of this and continue to play at this level, I can say that I’d feel okay if the Saints decided to go with another position than quarterback in the upcoming draft. Offensive MVP: Spencer Rattler Defensive MVP: Carl Granderson Special Teams MVP: NONE
By Caleb Yaccarino September 14, 2025
After a close loss to the Arizona Cardinals, the New Orleans Saints have a chance to bounce back against a depleted San Francisco 49ers team, but can they do it?
Show More