PFF Grades And Statistical Deep Dive Into The Saints Week 4 Loss

Jamie UK • October 4, 2023

        Each week I take a look into the advanced statistics provided by PFF, to see what (if any) interesting nuggets I can pick out from each Saints game. Including coverage stats, grades, pressure reports from both the offensive and defensive lines and anything else that sticks out.


How the grades work:

A rainbow colored scale with numbers 90 80 70 60 50 40 30

Top 5 Offensive Grades:

A blurred image of a table showing the ranks of players

        On paper a good week for the O-line, it looked this way in the game and the stats back it up, were they perfect? No, and the grades back that up but overall this was a better game for most of the starters. Week to week Trevor Penning is improving, I thought this was Penning's best game while watching live and PFF agrees. He posted an elite 91.0 run blocking which was an element of his game that was strangely lacking in the early weeks after being dominant as a rookie.


Bottom 5 Offensive Grades:

A blurred image of a table showing the ranks of players

        I’ve included the bottom 6 here as Winston only played 1 snap. Not hard to see why Prentice graded so poorly had a bad drop on third down and fumbled his only carry of the game. James Hurst continues to grade out poorly each week which falls in line with the general view on his game he’s looked really poor all year, his pass black grade this week? 13.5 was the second lowest in the league in week 4. Garcia also looked like he struggled live PFF are in agreement. These grades are another point of evidence to show the worth of Cesar Ruiz and after a torrid offseason Andrus Peat, who is clearly the right player to be starting at LG when back healthy (he left Sunday’s game with a concussion). After 3 stellar weeks, Chris Olave takes the 6th spot here with an uncharacteristically poor game from the star WR.


Top 5 Defensive Grades:

A blurred image of a table showing the ranks of players

        Another strong week for Yiadom who has been really impressive overall in place of Paulson Adebo. He was targeted 6 times surrendered 5 catches for only 32 yards with 1 TD given up, but had 1 interception and 1 PBU. On the TD he gave up similar to the Green Bay game he had very good coverage and the WR just made the play. Isaiah Foskey continues to score highly in PFF grades again had a strong week according to them in run defense, if the Saints see it the same then I think we start to see him getting more snaps. Malcolm Roach in particular graded out well here with a pressure and a very impressive 4 defensive stops in the run game.


Bottom 5 Defensive Grades:

A blurred image of a table showing the ranks of players

Not particularly surprised to see Shepherd and Lattimore this low, Shepherd had a very unnecessary roughing the passer penalty and registered 0 pressures. Lattimore was unusually poor in coverage surrendering 5 receptions on 5 targets for 78 yards. Surprised to see Bresee graded this low, he had his first solo sack and had a dominant TFL in the run game. He had a further 2 pressures and another defensive stop in the run game, Bresee looks like a real hit of a first-round pick.


Pressure Stats

Offense 

Trevor Penning- 2 total pressures (2 hurries) 97.7 efficiency score.

James Hurst- 3 total pressures (3 hurries) 96.5 efficiency score (not sure how can have this efficiency score but also receive a 13.5 pass-blocking grade, but here we are)

Erik McCoy- 2 pressures (1 sack and 1 hurry) 

Ryan Ramczyk- 1 total pressure (1 sack) 97.7 efficiency score.

Andrus Peat- 2 total pressures (1 hit and 1 hurry) 96.4 efficiency score.

Max Garcia- 1 total pressure (1 hurry) 96.7 efficiency score.

Landon Young- 0 pressures, 100 efficiency score

Alvin Kamara- 1 total pressure (1 hurry)

** Pass Blocking Efficiency - A PFF Signature stat measuring pressure allowed on a per-snap basis with weighting toward sacks allowed.


        12 total pressures were given up by the Saints (11 by the O-line) the second least of the season (they gave up 10 against the Packers. But only 2 sacks and 1 hit are the lowest marks of the year. Ramczyk continues his up-and-down year been really good in 2 games and really poor in the other 2, still would like your very highly paid RT to be giving up pressures rather than sacks but. 


Defense

Cam Jordan- 5 total pressures (1 hit and 4 hurries)

Bryan Bresee- 3 total pressures (1 sack and 2 hurries)

Khalen Saunders- 2 total pressures (2 hurries)

Carl Granderson- 1 total pressure (1 hurry)

Tanoh Kpassagnon- 1 total pressure (1 hurry)

Malcolm Roach- 1 total pressure (1 hit)

Jonathan Abram- 1 total pressure (1 hurry)


        This is where I feel pressures can be misleading, the Saints logged 14 pressures which at face value is not terrible, but it didn’t look like any of these pressures particularly affected Baker Mayfield or the Bucs passing game. These pressure figures are still better than a lot of games from last year but still not nearly good enough for the Saints defense to be elite. Cam Jordan has been far more disruptive this year from a statistics perspective he has 19 pressures so far in 4 games, he had 37 in 16 games last year.



Best of the rest 

Some other stats that jumped out:



  • Alvin Kamara had much more success running to the left side of the line, he rushed to the left side 7 times for 39 yards (5.5 YPC), compared to the 4 times he rushed to the right for a total of 12 yards (3 YPC).
  • Alontae Taylor continues to have really solid games in coverage bar one big play. Taylor was targeted 7 times, surrendered 5 receptions for 53 yards. 32 of those yards came on one catch to Chris Godwin (Godwin was targeted another 2 times with Taylor in coverage neither pass was completed).
  • It’s been well-documented that the Saints offense hasn’t been attacking the middle of the field, so I checked to see how true that is. Carr has attempted 124 passes so far this season he’s targeted the middle of the field (past 10 yards) 10 times and completed 2 of those passes for 57 yards, with 1 interception. The stats do indeed back up the narrative around the Saints passing attack.


Make sure to follow me on Twitter and Instagram @SaintsReportUK, for much more Saints content and discussion throughout the 2023 season and beyond.

A quick share helps us a lot!

By Kaden Arkeder September 11, 2026
It is week one folks, we made it to the 2026 season! This is the first season in a while where personally I feel optimistic going into the season thanks to Tyler Shough and what the Saints were able to show at the end of the 2025 season. Coupled with what the Saints did in the offseason in free agency and the draft the Saints and Saints fans should feel like the team has a real shot at winning the division and making the playoffs. Their first obstacle they will have to overcome on their path to accomplishing the goal is the Detroit Lions. The Lions will prove to be a good litmus test for the Saints in week one. The Lions have been a championship contender the last few years under the stewardship of Dan Campbell and will look to continue their fortune by taking care of business at home against the Saints. The Saints however are not facing the Lions at their peak as they finished last season with a 9-8 win loss record after being a double digit win team the two prior seasons. The Lions will also not have at least two key players in their secondary as both Brian Branch and Kerby Joseph are on injured reserve while two of their corners are on the injury report albeit listed as full participants as I am writing this. So the Saints will look to capitalize through the passing game with those key players out for this matchup. I expect Chris Olave to be targeted early and often in this game and for the role players around him to come up big on some key plays throughout the game. Speaking of role players I am curious to see if either or both of the rookie receivers in Barion Brown and Bryce Lance have any big moments in the game after having a great offseason and preseason. Outside of the rookie receivers I am curious to see if Juwan Johnson will be able to build on the productive season he had last year. With the absence of Jordyn Tyson to begin the season there should be plenty of opportunity for targets in the passing game outside of Chris Olave’s share. In regards to the running game I expect the Saints to give Etienne a heavy workload against the Lions if Kamara is not active for the game but there is optimism Kamara is ahead of schedule and could play against the Lions. I will be very interested to see how Etienne does in his debut with the team and how he will be utilized in the offense. There was talk during training camp the Saints have a package with both Etienne and Kamara on the field so if both are active I will be keeping an eye out for that personnel package. The Saints will look to start off the season strong on the ground after being one of the least effective teams running the ball last season. Hopefully the addition of David Edwards and Etienne combined with Kellen Moore along with most of the players being in year two of Kellen Moore’s system will aid them in running the ball better this season. Adin Hutchinson will look to be the main challenge the offensive line will face against the Lions defensive line as he had a standout 2025 campaign with 14.5 sacks along with an interception. If the Saints young tackles in Kelvin Banks and Taliese Fuaga are able to hold up well against Hutchinson they should be able to hold up well against the best edge rushers for the rest of the season. On the defensive side of the ball this will be very much a good challenge for them as the Lions have some marquee players on offense the defense will be tasked with slowing down. Amon Ra St. Brown and Jhamyr Gibbs are the two skill position players to key in on for the Saints in this game but role players like Sam LaPorta and Jameson Williams can absolutely be a difference maker for the Lions on any given Sunday. I think my two favorite matchups on this side of the ball will be watching Chase Young against Penei Sewell and the Saints young secondary against Amon Ra St. Brown. Chase Young had ten sacks in twelve games last season and will look to continue this success against one of the league’s best tackles in Penei Sewell. Unfortunately his running mate in Cameron Jordan will be unavailable in this game so look for a steady rotation at edge opposite of Chase Young throughout the game. Amon Ra St. Brown is the type of receiver Jared Goff looks for early and often throughout the game and can be moved around their offensive formations even though he plays primarily in the slot. How the Saints plan to contain or slow down Amon Ra will be fascinating to watch. Overall, I expect this to be a close game between the Saints and Lions where both teams should have ample opportunities to put up points against each other. There are so many little story lines to follow as the Saints start the regular season and in this game I can’t wait to follow. Week one usually has a fair amount of chaos to the games so you can never discount a crazy outcome here or elsewhere throughout the league. There should be plenty to discuss coming out of week one. Alright enough from me, talk to you all on the other side and geaux Saints! Injury Designations Lions DB - Christian Izien - Questionable Saints TE - Oscar Delp - OUT Edge - Cameron Jordan - OUT RB - Audric Estime - OUT RB - Alvin Kamara - Questionable
By Dusty Thibodeaux September 11, 2026
ULM enters the Saturday afternoon game +9.5 to UAB
Show More