Did the Saints Move too Fast?

Patty V • March 8, 2023

This is a subtitle for your new post

The Saints have their guy. With the recent acquisition of Derek Carr, the New Orleans Saints have seemingly solidified their Quarterback position for at least the next two seasons. I’m still not able to fully comprehend the contract that Carr has signed, but one thing remains true: the cap is a myth. 


There is a lot to be said about what Carr brings to the table, and the opinions seem to be mixed amongst fans when it comes to the signing. If you are one to put stock into winning percentage for a QB, Carr may not be your guy. He is a career 63-79. He is also coming off of one of his worst seasons as a pro, being benched late in the year as the team signified they were ready to move away from their vet. 


With this being known, should we be alarmed? My short answer is no, but I’ll elaborate. First and foremost, I’ll start with Josh McDaniels. McDaniels, outside of New England has proven to make every wrong decision, and as an “offensive guru”, has had the 19th, 20th, 31st, and 12th ranked scoring offenses. The quarterback of that 12th ranked offense? Derek Carr. 


Through Carr’s history he has been troubled with playing for a franchise that has been extremely questionable at best. In his nine years he’s had 6 coaches, 4 offensive coordinators, some of which left and returned, and 3 GMs. He’s also had to deal with a head coach being removed to scandal, and a WR who is now known for one of the worst accidents in NFL history. Oh, he also dealt with relocation. During all of this, he’s been faced with competing against a Chiefs dynasty that has been nothing but a model of excellency. 


So, what are you gettin in Carr? First and foremost, you are getting a leader. Carr has been nothing but professional throughout his entire career, handling animosity with grace at every turn. From a talent standpoint, he is a former MVP candidate with a live arm, who has excellent pocket mobility. He makes good reads, PRE SNAP ADJUSTMENTS, and quick decisions. The last two have been major issues for the Saints under center since Drew Brees retired. Also, outside of Matt Stafford, Carr has the second most career 4th quarter comebacks in the NFL in his career for active players. (Stay retired Brady)


However, even with all that, we now know Lamar Jackson is potentially available to any team willing to make a godfather offer. So the question is, did the Saints move too fast? I’ll answer like this: maybe, but you’ll never know. I’m always on board with going all in on getting an MVP caliber quarterback, who is a generational talent. Would the Saints have had a shot? You’ll never know. However, what I can say, is that the Saints should be happy with what they have, and Carr is an excellent fit for this team. 


Follow Patty on Twitter

A quick share helps us a lot!

By Greyson Jenkins January 4, 2026
New Orleans Saints 17 - 19 Atlanta Falcons The Saints' season is officially over. As sad as it is to say that, this season ended on a much more positive note than I expected, and has me actually looking forward to the offseason, not dreading it. The defense finished on a positive note, Tyler Shough is definitely the guy for at least the next few seasons, and Kellen Moore improved over the second half of the year. If the season finished how we expected prior to Shough saving the team, this offseason would be much more bleak in appearance. This is supposed to be a week 18 recap, but why recap a game no one really had any expectations for or cared about? No one, not even us Saints fans or analysts, really expected Shough to be able to do much with this offensive group, and he couldn’t really. Sure, he made a few really good plays, but you could tell Kellen Moore was struggling to find plays that he felt confident running with the receivers, and I don’t view that as a negative, just a bad scenario for everyone. Because of this, I am not going to write this really as a week 18 recap, but more as a short preview of this offseason. Chase Young Chase Young has made it clear that he is the best young player on this Saints team. Maybe you could swap him out with Chris Olave, but I struggle to overlook his incredible performances and constant clutch play in big moments to close out the year. He finished this game with one and a half sacks and three tackles for losses, but should have even had one more sack and a forced fumble on his stat sheet. Mickey Loomis seemingly has gotten away with the deal of a lifetime, sorry Loomis haters, by signing Young to a three-year deal for only $17 million per year on average. That is more than $10 million less than what the top 10 defensive end salaries are on a per-year basis, and Young has 10 sacks in 12 games played. While watching this one, I texted my buddies and said that Young is a top 10 EDGE in the league at this point, but they disagree. Although he may not be right now, Chase Young is quickly improving and becoming what everyone expected him to be when he came into the league. If he continues down this path, it would be extremely reasonable for him to try and get a pay raise after next season. Going into this offseason, the Saints must add at least one other piece to the defensive end rotation, so teams are forced to take their focus off of Young and open up the opportunity for even more plays by him. Tyler Shough Tyler Shough did not by any means have a perfect game; he finished 23 of 39 for 259 yards and a touchdown and an interception. However, as I said earlier, I don’t think anyone expected him to with the weapons at his disposal. He led the team down the field multiple times, and a Charlie Smyth missed field goal, and Dante Pettis offensive pass interference made this game appear worse offensively than it was. He made some throws and plays out of scheme that once again added to the current mindset that he is the team’s future, so I am not worried about the interception that came late in the fourth quarter on the tenth or so double slant pattern of the game. However, I will say that Shough’s ability to make things work at times with this battered of a weapon room is impressive in itself, and means that if the team decides to go and get him weapons in the draft or free agency, he can be even more successful. I’d really like the Saints to leave the draft with one of the following: Jeremiyah Love, Jordyn Tyson, Makai Lemon, or Elijah Sarratt. If they do that, I think this offense alongside Shough would be extremely fun to watch next season. The Defense The Saints' defense finished the season without allowing a fourth-quarter touchdown since Week 11 against the Falcons. Yes, week 11. Although I felt the defense started off pretty rough, the second half of the season was a true testament to Brandon Staley’s abilities as a defensive coordinator. The Saints' defense improved this season in both total scoring and yardage allowed in comparison to last season, at 17th and 9th, respectively, before this game. They played another great game here with what should have been two turnovers if it weren’t for a bad call by the refs on the Chase Young strip-sack. Quincy Riley and Jonas Sanker both have been massive additions to this side of the ball, and Danny Stutsman appears to have the potential to be good whenever Werner or Davis leave. If the Saints decide to run it back with this same defense and bring back the vets, it would not be the worst thing in the world, but I would still like to see them bring in more young talent. Closing Time This season was my first writing for the team, and I really enjoyed recapping all of the highs and lows of the season and trying to let you guys know exactly how I felt about the team week in, week out. As much as I hate this team missing the playoffs and the season ending today, I’m happy I had this opportunity and look forward to doing the same next season. I may write a few offseason articles, but if not, I will definitely have a few Saints-focused episodes on my YouTube channel, Jenks Island. Until next time, Who Dat!! Offensive MVP: Tyler Shough Defensive MVP: Chase Young Special Teams MVP: NONE (Please fire Phil Galiano)
By Caleb Yaccarino January 3, 2026
The final game of the season is here!
Show More